House Republicans pass prohibition on automatic payments to unions

By T.W. Budig
ECM Capitol Reporter

A bill prohibiting the deduction of union dues or fees from state child care assistance payments to day care providers passed the Republican House on a 74 to 55 vote on Thursday, Feb. 9.

House Majority Leader Matt Dean, R-Dellwood, speaks at a Capitol press conference on Feb. 9 on legislation prohibiting union dues or fees from being automatically withdrawn from state child care payments. Bill supporter Sen. Ted Lillie, R-Lake Elmo, listens in the background. (Photo by T.W. Budig)

The Senate is expected to take up the legislation next week in health and human services committee.

An outgrowth of the child care unionization dispute sparked by DFL Gov. Mark Dayton’s executive order calling for a vote among some day care providers on a forming an union, Republicans depict the legislation as sensible precaution.

“This is not about political mileage,” said Sen. Ted Lillie, R-Lake Elmo, speaking at a Republican press conference prior to the House floor session.

“This is about families in Minnesota,” said Lillie, whose wife operated a day care business.

Republicans argue the state has no business serving as the go-between in the payment of union dues. Lillie, for one, said the federal government prohibits union dues or fees from being automatically taken out of federal payments.

But no such law exists in Minnesota, Republicans say.

On the House floor, the “simple bill,” as Republicans called it, drew fire from Democrats.

Rep. Joe Atkins, DFL-Inver Grove Heights, attacked the legislation on several levels.

He styled the bill as sending “a big government, condescending, paternalistic message” to day care providers.

Atkins also questioned exactly whose money Republicans were attempting to apply a restriction to? Was it the state’s money? Or is it really the provider’s money? Atkins asked.

Rep. Joe Atkins, DFL-Inver Grove Heights, depicted the Republican bill as Big Brother reaching in after someone's wallet. (Photo by T.W. Budig)

But Republicans, such as Rep. Tara Mack, R-Apple Valley, argued they were keeping within the tenor of established practices.

And Republicans insisted day care providers could spend their state payments as they saw fit.

Union dues or fees just can’t be automatically garnished from them.

Still, House Minority Leader Paul Thissen, DFL-Minneapolis, slammed Republicans for abandoning their ballyhooed job-creation emphasis.

“Are you kidding me?” shot back House Majority Leader Matt Dean, R-Dellwood.

The lawsuit reform bills sent to the governor were all about job-creation, Dean said. Dean also criticized Dayton for interfering in the private sector with his day care unionization effort.

Union activists slammed Republicans on their latest effort.

“I wish they spent as much time protecting families as we do,” said Lisa Thompson, St. Paul child care provider and member of the American Federation of State, County Municipal Employees Child Care Providers Together, in a statement.

“Instead, they cut child care and cut unions,” she said.


    This fight for automatic Union Dues withdrawal from state pay is from the PRO-CHOICE Progressive people. They really do not want people to have a choice other than “their” choice! In Wisconsin we used to have to pay Union Dues automatically if we were a Union Member or not. We had no choiice! We now have a choice! The Union can still get theri dues…just not by legalized theft of them from us automatically without any choice.
    If you want to belong to a Union and pay their dues, by all means do so! Just don’t force everyone who chooses to take a certain job to pay dues whether or not they have chosen to be members or not.
    I TRUELY am PRO-CHOICE and I am very happy that my Governor and State Officials have given me that right back as a state worker that was forced to turn over a part of my paycheck to people that I do not personally know, but who promise to take care of me for that small price of legalized petty theft.
    I have now chocen to not pay Union Dues or be a member due to the sour taste left in my mouth by the past legalized crimes committed against me.

Purchase Photos

menards flyer promo